Are you looking for a home improvement task while you’re stuck inside? 

Is your bathroom feeling outdated and in need of a facelift?  

When planning a bathroom remodel in Ann Arbor, one of the most important decisions you'll face is whether to install a shower or bathtub. Your choice will affect not only your bathroom's functionality but also its overall aesthetic, cost, and even your home's resale value. 

To help you decide, let's break down the factors you should consider when choosing between a shower and a tub.

1. Lifestyle and Daily Use

Consider your daily routines and habits. Do you typically enjoy quick showers, or do you prefer long, relaxing soaks in the tub? If you're remodeling a family bathroom, keep in mind that bathtubs are often preferred for households with young children or pets. On the other hand, if you're creating a master suite or focusing on personal relaxation, a spacious walk-in shower may better suit your needs.

• Go for a shower: Ideal for those with busy schedules, seniors, or anyone who enjoys efficient, daily use.
• Choose a tub: Best for homes with young children, pet owners, or those who want a spa-like space for relaxation.

2. Space Considerations

Showers generally take up less floor space than bathtubs, making them perfect for smaller bathrooms or if you want to maximize available space. On the other hand, a freestanding or soaking tub can be a luxurious centerpiece if your bathroom has ample room.

• Small bathrooms: A sleek, modern shower may make better use of limited space.
• Larger bathrooms: Consider adding a freestanding tub or a shower-tub combo for a balanced layout.

3. Resale Value and Market Appeal

If you're thinking about how your remodel will affect your home's value, it's important to consider what potential buyers might prefer. In Ann Arbor, many homebuyers look for at least one bathtub, especially in family homes. That said, a luxurious walk-in shower can also be a big selling point, particularly in master bathrooms.

• To maximize resale value: If possible, include at least one tub in your home, even if it's in another bathroom. Otherwise, a high-end shower can be just as appealing.

4. Accessibility and Aging in Place

For homeowners planning to stay in their homes as they age, accessibility is a key factor. Showers, especially curbless or walk-in showers, are generally more accessible than bathtubs. They can be designed with features like grab bars, seating, and slip-resistant flooring for added safety and comfort. If accessibility is a concern, a shower may be a smarter long-term investment.

• For accessibility: Walk-in showers provide ease of use and can be designed for aging in place.
• For mobility needs: Bathtubs can be retrofitted with safety features, but may not be as convenient as a shower.

5. Cost Considerations

The cost of installing a shower vs. a tub will vary based on the type of fixture, materials, and the complexity of the installation. In general, bathtubs can be more expensive due to their larger size and the need for additional plumbing work. However, a custom, high-end shower can also carry a hefty price tag, especially if you add luxury features like body jets, steam systems, or intricate tile work.

• For a cost-effective remodel: A prefabricated shower can be less expensive than a tub, but high-end custom showers can increase the price.
• For luxury: A freestanding tub or a large, custom shower will likely be on the higher end of the cost spectrum.

Which Option is Best for Your Bathroom Remodel in Ann Arbor?

Ultimately, the best option for your bathroom remodel in Ann Arbor depends on your lifestyle, space, and long-term goals. If your primary focus is functionality and accessibility, a walk-in shower may be the perfect choice. If you’re seeking relaxation and luxury, a bathtub could be the ideal solution.

No matter your decision, working with a trusted residential contractor can help you find the perfect balance between style, function, and budget. 

If you're unsure which option is right for you, our team can guide you through the process and help bring your dream bathroom to life. Contact us today to get started!